Published Paper Details:

Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr. called R.W. Emerson's 1837 "The American Scholar" as "our intellectual Declaration of Independence"(Holmes, 115) and since its first publication in 1884 on the biography of Emerson, it has become a sort of objective correlative for the oration itself, used by every critics, theorists, editors and historians, as a way, somehow, to suggest the connotation and implication of the oration. But it is exorbitant to say that the phrase "our intellectual Declaration of Independence" has achieved the rank of critical euphemism, a phrase that has been overused to the point of being futile, pointless and unimportant". The American scholar", much like the oration itself, has come to occupy a kind of acontextual limboland where meaning is compromised if not lost altogether" (ESQ 37). What Holmes said to equip his depiction was this, "Nothing like it had been heard in the halls of Harvard since Samuel Adams supported the affirmative of the question, 'Whether it be lawful to trust the chief magistrate, if the commonwealth cannot otherwise be preserved.'"(Beach 24)